Custom Jewelry | Handcrafted by Beth Millner Jewelry


Looking for a unique piece of jewelry designed by Beth Millner? Start by filling out the custom order inquiry form, including your preference in metals, size and widths and your budget for the project. We work with recycled metals - copper, brass, sterling silver, yellow gold, palladium white gold, and rose gold. Click here for more information on our metal options. We also offer a variety of gemstones, including our locally-sourced Lake Superior Agates and Michigan Greenstone.

A custom design is a great opportunity to have your idea made into a special, unique piece of jewelry. We can work from your existing drawings and photographs or design something entirely new based on your style preferences and input. All pieces are carefully handcrafted by Beth and her assistants with the highest attention to quality and detail. We are committed to fast, friendly service from the initial design inquiries to the delivery of the final product.

Fill out the form below to get started!

What types of custom jewelry do you create?

We can create Custom Rings, Pendants and Earrings. We would love to collaborate to create a custom item just for you! To see custom designs Beth has made in the past, check out our Flickr album.

When should I place a custom order?

Custom orders have a 3 month turnaround time from downpayment, with the possibility of rush order upgrades available depending on the time of year and current order status. Please browse the album above to see examples of Beth's custom work, many created for special occasions like engagements, weddings, anniversaries and birthdays. 

Can I use my own stones or gold?

Unfortunately, we are unable to use your gold or most stones in our custom designs. We can use your diamond if it is 4mm or larger in diameter.  


Personalize your custom or inventory Beth Millner piece with engraving! Handwritten engraving in your choice of print or cursive, available on most jewelry. We only offer to engrave on Beth Millner pieces.

What's Next?

Once your form is submitted, Beth will take a 1-2 weeks to work up a basic concept for the design and you will be contacted with a quote for your project. All custom orders are subject to a custom design fee which is included in the quote. A 50% downpayment is required to initiate the order. After we receive the downpayment, Beth will put together a design template or sketch for your approval prior to fabrication of the piece upon request. When the piece is finished, you will be contacted for the final payment and the item will be ready for shipment or pickup.


Let customers speak for us

1416 reviews
Beautiful Ring

Simply beautiful ring. Bought one for each of my daughters. They both love it! Now I’m going to get myself one too.

Twig Branch Ring

Lake Superior Copper Agate Drop Pendant No. 4

I have been watching for an agate to show up with this much copper and when it did I couldn’t say no! This agate is stunning! I have a lot of BMJ pieces and plan to continue to expand my collection!


Absolute in love with my ring. Only reason for four stars is because when I received it, the ring was quiet tarnished looking already. It was a quick fix with the complimentary polishing square and it was shiny again.


Love my ring! I would love to get your name here in town at our local shops! They would love it! Let me know how I can help advocate for you!